Need help with Food Allergies & Special Diets? Join RAISE today. RAISE gives you access to The Allergy Chef, and loads of invaluable resources.

S’more Ice Cream Recipe

Free and Friendly Foods S'more Ice Cream

Late one night, when the kids should have been asleep, Kid Three wanted to be part of the conversation. The Papa and I were talking about supply and demand (at which point Kid Two wanted to get involved) and just all things related to the business. We then got on the topic of ice cream, and some of the ideas that I had to use with the machine, knowing that I wanted to have an ice cream theme week, and that I’m working on an ice cream book. Kid Three suggested Bubble Gum Ice Cream, which I thought would be really cool, at which point S’more Ice Cream hit me like a ton of bricks (as did many other good ideas). Once made, the kids went wild for this ice cream flavor. I was afraid the marshmallows were going to get hard and be weird, but in the end, everything turned out just right, and they all lived happily ever after. Yup, still trying to be a comedian. So, I present you with S’more Ice Cream!

Allergy Status: Wheat/Gluten Free, Dairy Free, Egg Free, Nut Free, Peanut Free, Sesame Free, Vegan, Soy Free Compatible

For Soy Free: Use a safe non-dairy milk alternative. Be sure to source soy free marshmallows (not the Dandees brand) and graham crackers (not Kinnikinnick). I have yet to see GF SF graham crackers, but that doesn’t mean they aren’t out there, and you could always make some. However, if you can have gluten, there are plenty of soy free options.

This ice cream starts with a Soy Milk Vanilla base:
2 cups Organic Soy Milk, Unsweetened
3 TBSP Organic Kuzu Root Starch
1/4 tsp Sea Salt
3/4 cup Organic Sugar (you can use less if you’d like)
1 TBSP Organic Vanilla Extract
1/8 tsp Guar Gum

Mix-in Ingredients:
2/3 cup Mini Chocolate Chips (Enjoy Life is Top 8 Free), divided
45 Mini Marshmallows (we used Dandies)
5 Kinnikinnick Graham Crackers, cut into small pieces
1/3 cup Enjoy Life Chocolate Chips, to fold in at the start of the process

Related post: S’more Bars Recipe

Remove 6 TBSP of the milk and combine with the Kuzu. Allow the starch to dissolve, then mix all of the ingredients together in your blender or Vitamix. Fold in 1/3 cup of the chocolate chips. Pour into your ice cream machine. Yes, you’re going to start with chocolate chips in the machine.

Our ice cream machine has a duration of 60 minutes. When there were 25 minutes left, I added in the mix-ins, a little at a time. Our general technique is to drop some in, let it rotate several times so the item goes into the ice cream itself, then add more in. This helps ensure even distribution of the goods. With this recipe, we also alternated when adding items: a little chocolate chips, a little graham cracker, a little marshmallows, repeat.

When this is all done, be ready for a happy household 🙂

Free and Friendly Foods S'more Ice Cream
Almost time to add the mix-ins.


Free and Friendly Foods S'more Ice Cream
Yes, that’s a paper towel, also known as a make shift cutting board, also known as I don’t want to dirty anymore dishes today.


Free and Friendly Foods S'more Ice Cream


Free and Friendly Foods S'more Ice Cream
Paper towel wasn’t working. The kids will have to load extra dishes.


Free and Friendly Foods S'more Ice Cream


Free and Friendly Foods S'more Ice Cream


Free and Friendly Foods S'more Ice Cream


Free and Friendly Foods S'more Ice Cream
All done. This was when we realized how much better the machine does with mix-ins. The texture was much more consistent, and no frozen edges.


Free and Friendly Foods S'more Ice Cream


Free and Friendly Foods S'more Ice Cream

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© Copyright Free and Friendly Foods, LLC

Subscribers receive news, recipes, news, and of course, LEGO.

Success! You're on the list :)

There was an error while trying to send your request. Please try again.

Food & Lego Blog will use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you and to provide updates and marketing.